They are not self seeking, self centered, or greedy like the contemporary worship circle is.
Interesting that while you slam someone for being critical of your favorite band... you throw a blanket of critisism over an entire genre of music and musicians. If we can dispense with the hypocracy around here, perhaps we might get something accomplished for the kingdom.
Now... I would actually like to address the topic. I dont know much about ATF. I am familiar with the bands and speakers who "perform" (I have a hard time calling it ministry... especially the music part) at these types of rallies. I have also attended many events like ATF.
I will never say that God does not move upon some that are in attendance. I am sure He does. But my experience has been that most do not come away with any lasting changes. It's the same old argument that we need to entertain the masses in order to reach them. Sure, there is some preaching, and God's Word does not come back void. But I am convinced more and more everyday that what our teens need is not entertainment and huge productions with lights and smoke. They need the Word of God.
For instance... we homeschool. Many of the homeschool families we know are some of the most dedicated and serious Christians you will ever meet. I see 12 year old who [b]study[/b] the Bible. Yesterday I flipped thru my 10 yr old's Bible and was pleased that he has marked and noted in his Bible quite a bit. A trait he's picked up from me. I've seen many of these kids grow up to go on to Bible school to become pastors and missionaries. They didnt spend their time and money going to concerts, or huge events (tho some did, and thats [b]ok[/b]!). They didnt need those things to validate their relationship with God, or to be lit "on fire"... they were already on fire because they were filled with the Word of God.
Ben will, I'm sure, take exception to this... but I've been around enough to know that the vast majority of church youth groups spend more time and energy on entertainment than they do serious Bible study and prayer. I know there are exceptions, but not many. Thats a fact. Ben can throw a hissy and tell me I'm wrong... but I'm not wrong.
When the [b]parents[/b] in the churches make Jesus Christ their priority in life instead of their career's, the TV, sports, etc... and begin to obey scripture and teach their children to do likewise... then things like ATF will not exist. But most "Christian" parents are too concerned with making payments on houses and cars that they cant afford, and too concerned about who's gonna win Survivor or American Idol. As long as that is true... the youth will suffer.
ATF is not evil. Dont misunderstand me. But the concept is flawed. It is a substitute for learning, studying, memorizing, obey and living out the Word of God. Show me a teenager who spends 1 hour a day (or more) in serious study of the Word and in prayer... and I'll show you a teenager who is too busy for Jesus to even attend ATF.
Just because you don't understand our culture, does not give you the right to say it is wrong.
This is a very telling statement. What culture? Biblical culture? Scriptural culture? Unfortunately today people want to be "just like" the world, thinking they will show people that "hey, Christians can be cool too!". Why? Paul didnt do that. Jesus said because the world [b]hated[/b] Him, we can expect it to hate us too. If the world thinks you're cool... you better examine your walk with God! Something is wrong.
I have gotten to the point where I dont care what the world thinks of me. I have the Truth, and the truth has set me free.
Ben, you can argue with me on this all you want. But I'm right about this. And if you belong to a "culture" that sets itself at odds with precious saints who have been walking with God for quite awhile (such as PaulWest), then you're in the wrong "culture", my friend. You should be chasing after people like him, trying to soak up as much wisdom as you can... not being in rebellion toward them.
You're 20. When I was 20 I was a fool. I wasnt saved, so I was a real fool. At least you're saved, my friend. You have a leg up on me. When you get to be 39 like I am... and you've seen some things... I bet you'll be singing a different tune, brother. And when you hit 80... wow, imagine where you will be in your walk with the Lord! And what will remain? Only those things that matter to God.
Krispy