There are some aspects about this news release that disturbs me – and not merely the quotes of the Episcopalian rector.
For one thing, this is not news – this issue surrounding nomenclature has been around for years.
The title chosen by this particular reporter, was deliberately and carefully created – not as an aim to shed light, but to incite controversy – which is exactly what keeps the press in business and feeds the insatiable appetite of the public. So really, this reporter just found a pitiful twig to keep religious controversy burning and make enough smoke to obscure the truth. We shouldn’t take the bate!
Of course, the Lordship of Christ is foundational to the authentic Christian walk. But THAT point never came through in the article. The evangelical pastor, who apparently “blasted” the rector (Note word choice here!) did not shed any light, other than to point out his disapproval, calling it ‘nonsense”.
But wait - what exactly did he call “nonsense’. That is not clear. Is it this one:
We do not pray as though we expect the big guy in the sky to come and fix everything."
I say, this in itself is a good point, and could have been an ideal point to shed light on the meaning of lordship - including what it is NOT (ex God doesn't force anyone into his kingdom; his lordship is NOT like human authoritarianism).
Note also what she said:
"Jesus was a rabbi and teacher. It was a relationship of mentoring, looking up to him for that kind of companionship."
Note rather than explaining the servanthood of Christ’s earthly ministry, Mahler himself took her point right into absurdity:
"Jesus – the Lord – called His disciples to follow Him. He did not follow them ... He was not a mere 'mentor' and 'companion,'"
She never implied the emboldened words. Of course we don’t really know, because we only have about three quotes from her – just enough – for the press - that is.
How sad, that we miss so many good opportunities to proclaim our Lord and Savior to a dying world. Too many evangelicals prefer to squabble or defend the rightness of "their" side.
And the press and the media love it too!
Diane