I come from a tradition that has used this in the past and still does, but rarely...maybe the people have gotten holier? :-? Not really.
I often wonder about why our churches will not excommunicated those that are strifeful? or those that have a serious problem with anger or liars? Sure, they will in a heartbeat not even reconsider unrepentant adulterers, fornicators...
About liars, gossipers...you hear something and say "I do not believe it." So, does this mean the speaker is a liar? Some people are very careless about reporting news/rumors without checking out the facts before repeating it. You have a lot of conflict in churches who allow rumors to exist without being challenged. OK, since this is a form of lying and it is allowed to exist and then what will happen next? Strife. Then what? anger..then what? So we do not allow unrepentant adulterers, murders to abide in the brotherhood peaceably but allow those that sow discord...methinks there is something seriously wrong...
When I think of the past, it seems to me if a certain brother - many years ago - would have been forcibly dealt with, it would have saved our brotherhood a ton of grief in the years since. His children, grandchildren have all been seriously effected by the spirit of criticism they grew up with.
Serious issue - now will have to listen to hear what Washer has to say.
ginnyrose