First, I would like to thank the mind that dared to ask.
I know this is long and you are all caught up in defending your view points but please read it all.
As with any Biblical truth, there are two sides to the coin.
Justification is the act of being reconciled to God , and made children of mercy rather that children of wrath.
But there is a problem, God is holy and can not have a fellowship with any thing that is not.
There is another problem, God is infinite , does not have beginning or days or end of life. He lives outside of time. When a sin is committed, it is played before His holy eyes for eternity no matter how small this sin is. Nothing that man can do can stop the wrath of God from burning in anger against that sinner, not because God enjoys or find delight in being wrathful, but His holy nature and His very being is to be in opposition to anything unholy. He can not help it.
God in His wisdom and mercy had found away in Christ, Himself in human flesh to solve the problem of fellowshipping with man. In Christ, the God-man God the Father can stop sin committed by the redeemed from playing before him for eternity by laying it on the eternal Christ. Only Christ can purchase eternal salvation for man-kind because of his eternal nature.
This is really crucial and what makes Christianity different from other religions. People view God as holding a scale ( the old kind with two sides that you see in courtrooms ) and weighing their good deeds and bad deeds and the side that goes down is the winning side. If someone had done more good deeds than bad, then he is safe. This is a pagan perception of God. Our God is not that way, that is why a small sin like a lie committed by someone is sufficient to send this person to hell for eternity, even if it was the only sin he had ever committed in all his life, even if that person had done good deeds for the rest of his life to pay for that sin. It is not sufficient. Only Christ sacrifice and blood can pay for that sin, for the sins of the whole world if the whole world would believe on Him.
The conclusion of the first side of the coin is: No one will make it to eternal life without their sins past, present, and future laid on Christ.
This is the sweet half that everyone likes to hear, but wait, there is more truth that is hard to swallow, the bitter half.
The other side of the coin:
At the time of Justification, reconciliation with God is achieved, when a sinner believes in Christ sacrifice on the cross and repents of his sin( meaning to feel a great remorse for ever offending God’ s holiness and serving the Devil, His enemy ) Two things must take place. Restitution to man, and restitution to God. While Christ takes care of the latter when we come to Him by faith, we must take care of the former and make restitutions to those who were hurt by our sins, because that also gives glory to God in heaven when we proclaim to others that we are now followers of a holy God who hates sin.
At justification , out PAST SINS are taken care of.
But he that lacketh these things is blind, and cannot see afar off, and hath forgotten that he was purged from his PAST SINS. 2 Pet 1:9
Whom God hath set forth to be a propitiation through faith in his blood, to declare his righteousness for the remission of the SINS THAT ARE PAST, through the forbearance of God; Rom 3:25
In that sense, to say to someone that if they believe on Christ, their past, present , and future sins are forgiven is deception and unbiblical language. If that was the case, the Christian life would have been a piece of cake.
The Bible says that all our sins were forgiven. Imagine your life a sheet of paper written all over with sins. At the moment of justification, that sheet of paper was wiped clean. In biblical language, the crimson stained garment was washed as white as snow. But that does not mean that the sheet of paper can not be filled again, or the garment stained a again, that does not mean that the washed sow can not go back to her wallowing places or the dog to his vomit.
Now the big question
How then can the two sides of the coin be reconciled? How is it true that no one can make it to eternal life without all the sins they have ever committed being laid on Christ due to His eternal nature and our inability to please God on our own due to God’s infinitely holy nature. And how is it that we are told by the Scripture that only our past sins are taken care of at justification.
First, it is assumed in the Scriptures that those who are washed will not go back to their old way of life. The Bible is filled with exhortations, warnings, and question marks to indicate the amazement of the author( the Holy Spirit) at how can someone desire again their old conduct of living after they have tasted God’ s goodness and forbearance. It grieves the heart of God to see a backslidden believer.
1ohn 1:2
My little children, these things write I unto you, that ye SIN NOT. And if any man sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous:
The way to reconcile the two sides is repentance, on the part of the sinner, and asking the Father to cover the sin with the blood of Christ, but that is for those who have a mind to SIN NOT. If they sin when they tried hard not to, they may come to God pleading the blood of Christ.
Friends,
There are many people who were justified but will not make it to eternal life because of a faulty understanding of the gospel they were given. We are given everything that we need for life and godliness. The warnings in the Scriptures about the impossibility to renew for a second time those who were once renewed are real. They are there to serve a function to bring the backslidden sinner to a climax of agony and remorse over his sin without which forgiveness will not be granted.
Many well meaning teachers have tried to explain away those passages to fit them with their theology to give sinners hope, but in reality it ended up creating a breed of believers with a harlot’s for-head , un ashamed, and un remorseful for offending God’s holiness.