SimpleLiving
Jul 12, 2011
I'm all for anything that simplifies things. The loss of avatars isn't really a loss at all.
I don't know anything about creating or running a forum. I don't know what kind of costs are involved, either. But, if I may be so bold, this forum set-up seems impractical altogether. The operation of the audio, visual sermons is okay, but the forums (and their features) seem difficult and a bit archaic.
With the problems you've been having, would it be easier to update the forums to a layout that's more common and easy to use? A larger font and wider screens would be kinder on the eyes to read. This forum is also the only one I know of where the posts are in reverse order and there is no direct search feature.
These aren't complaints, mind you. Just general observances. I don't know if they are cost issues or technological ones for those who operate the site, but I put them out there as simple suggestions for possible consideration.
TaylorOtwell
Jul 13, 2011
They make it easier to identify who is writing at a glance. I would keep them.
ccchhhrrriiisss
Jul 13, 2011
While I don't know that they matter much in the content, I do think that the avatars help provide a distinction between who is making a comment. I have noticed some confusion sometimes when someone incorrectly attributed a statement to the wrong person. I have been mistaken about who was saying certain statements in some discussions, and I notice that it is easier to make a distinction regarding who is speaking by the presence of an avatar.
I'm not sure if the "operating in the Spirit" idea would make much of a difference in an online forum. It is true that we should all be walking in the Spirit. Unfortunately, some people are quick to question your "walking ability" if you don't line up with what their own particular sets of beliefs (including non-essentials). Even some of the Apostles and other believers in the early church had disagreements within their actions, beliefs and discussions.
Even now, we have many believers from different backgrounds who make comments. Those comments can often turn into debate or aggression when someone says something that the other person doesn't agree with or doesn't believe lines up with their own notion of what beliefs are the result of "operating in the Spirit." After all, many outlandish claims are often shared by people who believe that they came to such revelation after "walking in the Spirit." In an online forum of diverse believers, I think that it is the comments -- and the spirit and attitude behind them -- that serve to divide the Body of Christ more than an avatar or screen name.
Greg, I will be remembering this in prayer. I pray that the Lord grant you wisdom regarding this and every decision pertaining to this greatly appreciated website.