BSBKJVWEBYLTASVBBEWMBT4TDBY|HymnsMusicDonate
Menu
Articles

War No More

K
KingJimmy Dec 21, 2011

War No More

This past week marked the end of the war in Iraq. The war has lasted almost a decade, cost almost 1 trillion dollars to fight, and has resulted in a death toll of an estimated 150,000 people. Of this war, the Church of Jesus Christ in America has had little to say.

Something is wrong with this picture.

There is a growing burden upon my heart in recent years at the relative silence coming from the Church in regard to war. When anything is said, the more liberal factions of the Church are generally found opposing war, and the more conservative factions of the Church are usually found to be supporting it. There’s usually some sort of argument between the two groups. But this generally amounts to nothing more than both sides rehashing where they stand in regard to the debate surrounding the thousand-year old Augustinian “Just War” theology. It’s mostly an abstract academic debate that does little to shape the consciousness of the Church, and worse, offers no prophetic witness to a world at war.

Lest anybody think I am taking any sort of self-righteous stance on the issue, let me say outright that I say all these things to my own shame. War has mostly been an abstract and ghostly issue to me. Apart from having a younger brother who spent some time in the military, my knowledge of war has been something I’ve only read about in history books, debated about in an ethics class, or watched on Fox News. Because I live in America, apart from such considerations, I’ve not really had to confront the issue head on. I’ve had more “important things” to think and talk about after all.

You are probably like me in this regard. The issue of war is something you’ve given little thought to. After all, you’ve been pursuing your best life now, advancing your career, raising your children, and trying to keep up with the Joneses. You attend a mid-week Bible study that helps you to become a better father, mother, or leader in the community. You battle to keep your finances in order, have a good self-esteem, and overcome some dirty habits. And praise God, Jesus Christ came to the world, died, and rose again, all so He could help you become a better you after all!

Our Christianity has become too self-absorbed. Our theology is too abstract. We are not Christ-centered in our thinking. And as a result, we have no clear word of God to give a lost and dying world that measures history by the wars she’s fought. It is a shameful thing that hundreds of millions of people created in the image of God can be destroyed from the face of the earth through violent bloodshed, and the Church of Jesus Christ can do nothing more in its witness than debate theological riddles and parrot cute truisms. We should be disturbed by this.

In this brief essay, I want to offer a rather unique and what I believe to be Biblical perspective on the topic of Christ and the response of the Church to war. And I want to do so without directly engaging important theologians and intellectual giants like St. Augustine or Stanley Hauerwas. I don’t want to talk much about “just war theory” or “pacifism.” I don’t want to talk about the proper role of government or the right of self-defense. I believe all of these abstract things just muddy the waters, and prevent us from seeing clearly. For these topics, as important as they are, fail to get to the heart of the issue. They are merely the branches of a much larger tree, whose roots we have long ignored.

It is my contention that if we want to adhere to a Biblical perspective on this topic, we must truly understand and grasp who Jesus Christ is, and the task with which God sent Him into the world to accomplish. In doing such, then not only will move away from the self-absorbed American Christian lifestyle familiar to so many of us, but we will move away from abstract theologians like Augustine or Hauerwas, and be able to speak a clear and definitive word from God to a world that is consumed with war. Such a word can only issue out of a revelation that comes from us understanding the “messianic task” that God had charged Christ with, and the relationship of the Church to that task.

The Messianic Task

In Genesis, we read of a perfect world created by God that has gone bad. Because of the rebellion of Adam in the garden of Eden, sin and death crept into this world. An all consuming curse was unleashed into creation, destroying every good thing God had created. A world that was at peace had suddenly become violent. To rectify the problem, God promised a solution. One day, a child would be born that would reverse the curse unleashed in the garden, and instead of death and destruction reigning, universal blessing would once again overtake the world. God would one day redeem all of creation, and restore everything to the state it was in prior to the fall.

In Genesis 12, God promised Abraham that through his seed all the nations of the earth would become blessed. By means of a miraculous birth, God set the wheels of redemptive history rolling. Abraham would give birth to Isaac, Isaac would give birth to Jacob, and one day through this lineage, the Messiah would be born into this world. As history progressed, God began to reveal more and more about the One that would be born King of the Jews.

From Moses to Malachi, the prophets began to paint a portrait of who the Messiah would be, and the age He would usher in with His coming. While all the prophets give witness to Christ in some measure, none write about Him more fully the prophet Isaiah.

Through his oracles, we understand how Christ would come into the world through the womb of a virgin. From Isaiah we know of the miraculous ministry that would accompany the life of Jesus. Through Isaiah we understand that the Messiah must be rejected, suffer, die, and be resurrected. And in these things, Isaiah revealed to us the ultimate significance of the Messiah, and the great things God would accomplish through Him, and the role He would play in the great redemption narrative. In Isaiah we have the greatest summary statements of Christ given by any of the prophets.

And in one of those greatest prophetic pronouncements regarding Christ from the prophet Isaiah, and a passage that really speaks to me and the topic at hand, is the oracle of Isaiah 2:1-4:

The word which Isaiah the son of Amoz saw concerning Judah and Jerusalem. Now it will come about that In the last days the mountain of the house of the LORD will be established as the chief of the mountains, And will be raised above the hills; And all the nations will stream to it. And many peoples will come and say, "Come, let us go up to the mountain of the LORD, to the house of the God of Jacob; That He may teach us concerning His ways and that we may walk in His paths." For the law will go forth from Zion and the word of the LORD from Jerusalem. And He will judge between the nations, and will render decisions for many peoples; And they will hammer their swords into plowshares and their spears into pruning hooks. Nation will not lift up sword against nation, and never again will they learn war. - (Isaiah 2:1-4; NASB)

In this passage, Isaiah speaks of the establishment of the kingdom of God, the rule of the Messiah, the evangelization of the Gentile world, and the impact that the word of God would have on the nations that heard His word. After such a breathtaking vision, is it no wonder Isaiah would later call the Messiah the Prince of Peace, and say that the distant coastlands were eagerly awaiting Him and His law?

For through the establishment of the kingdom of God, Isaiah says that the teachings of Christ would be so powerful that they would cause men to beat the tools of their warfare into instruments fashioned for harvest. Through the word He speaks, transformed men would transform their swords into plowshares and their spears into pruning hooks. As a result of receiving the teachings Christ, Isaiah says, men would never again learn war.

If this oracle can be understood to be a part of God’s redemptive plans promised through Abraham, about how the Messiah in His task would transform the world from a place that is dominated by the death and destruction unleashed upon this world because of man’s fall, into a world where blessing reigns, then I think we would do well to meditate on this passage of Scripture, and the ramifications of it.

For if I understand this passage correctly, I understand Isaiah to say that after the coming of Christ and the establishment of the kingdom of God, should men learn war, it will not be the result of anything they learned from Him. For Christ in His kingdom teaches men that they should make war no more. If men should learn war, it is because they are the disciple of somebody other than Jesus Christ. For Christ would never teach His disciples how to wage war, not even a “just” one.

For war is nothing more than the product of nations failing to realize that Jesus Christ is King, and yielding themselves to His reign. If the nations would but submit to His rule and His reign, then they would once and for all be done with war. For Christ in His death and resurrection destroyed every reason nations have to destroy one another. No longer do men have to kill or be killed, and fight to survive. For in Christ the cosmos were fundamentally changed, and death has been defeated by the One who died and rose again. The curse has now been reversed, and every blessing has now been made available to all who would but put their faith in Him.

Our Prophetic Announcement

As disciples of Jesus Christ and ambassadors of His kingdom, we are given the joyous task of announcing to the world that the long awaited Messiah has come, and that His rule and His reign have begun. We have tidings of great joy to announce to all nations. Something epic has occurred. A new age has begun. It is an age in which men should no longer slay one another in fights over land and resources. It is an age in which men should no longer slay one another to secure life or liberty. For Christ has provided us with all these blessings, and many more, as an extension of His grace towards all of who would believe.

But sadly, as individuals living between the times and amongst men who don’t know the blessings of Christ, we are quick to lose sight of all these things. We know little to nothing of the messianic task, nor of our role in the kingdom of God. Instead, we get caught up in our very earthly lives, and lose sight of the heavenly perspective. And instead of prophetically announcing to the nations the rule and reign of Christ, and instructing them in His ways, we are quick to adopt the mindsets of people who don’t know of God’s redemptive story.

Soon, instead of telling men the million justifications we have for peace found in Christ, we find ourselves helping them to think of a million justifications for war. Caught up in our own self interests, the Church finds itself in the odd place of baptizing the wars of the nations, and giving them the “blessing” they so desire. Not only that, but we often find ourselves swelling the ranks of the armed forces. But this blessing is not the blessing of Christ. For the blessing of Christ reverses the destruction that began in the garden, it does not further it by means of war.

For Christ would teach men that you reap what you sow. War never ends in peace. It only begets more war. And in whatever nation the “just war” theory is preached in, it is never long before all that nation knows is just war. And why? Because it is fundamental to the fallen and sinful nature of mankind.

Nations never fight wars because they “have” to. Nations fight wars because they “want” to. They fight wars because the corrupted hearts are men are hell bent on it. Like an apple that naturally falls to the ground because of gravity, so men naturally incline themselves to make war because of sin. It is no coincidence that the prophets predict that the end to this side of eternity will be marked by the greatest of all wars. Because of the human condition, war is something that all the nations of the world naturally lean towards.

That is why men are so resistant to the idea of peace. We are quick to want to justify war and why we should kill somebody else, because it is in keeping with our own sinful nature. Which is why we are often hostile to those who would say we should pursue peace instead of war. Peacemakers are often branded by society as not being patriotic, as not supporting the troops, or “the cause.” Such men are often treated as heretics, not only by the nations, but also by the Church! And why? Because we are the sons of Adam who know nothing of peace.

Peacemakers are often slandered as being “pacifists.” That is, they are considered men who are willing to do nothing in the light of whatever danger, real or imagined, that a nation may be facing. They are pictured to be men who would do nothing but sit by and watch the Hitler’s of the world kill another six-million Jews. But this could be further from the truth, and in reality, is yet another attempt at men to justify war instead of justifying peace, never mind how well meaning such arguments sound.

The truth of the matter is, when a nation is faced with the inevitability of war, we as the Church have been given a great opportunity. Far from being pacifists, we are called to be activists. For we are given the opportunity to act on behalf of Jesus Christ, and prophetically announce to the nations that God has established a King who teaches the nations to war no more. We are given the opportunity to announce to the nation we live in that we will not participate in her wars, no matter how “just” they seem, because something greater than justice is here. The cosmos have been changed by Christ. And because of such, men and nations should now submit themselves to Him.

As Christians, we have the opportunity to announce that the blessings of peace that a nation pursues under the guise of war are unattainable apart from the present rule of Christ, and that what they are looking for can only be found in Him. If a nation pursues peace by means of war, it will come away empty handed every single time. For war only begets more war. It never produces peace. Peace can only come to a world at war as the blessing of Christ that flows from participating in the life of the kingdom of God. But where the rule of Christ is unknown, there can never be peace, only war.

Conclusion

This essay is by no means complete. While I believe it has exposed the fundamental reason for war, namely, that men and nations choose to live their lives independently of the present rule and reign of Jesus Christ as the King of all creation, so much more needs to be said that is not addressed here. Lord willing and time permitting, in the future I hope to write additional reflections on this important topic. But for now I believe it is sufficient to say that we as disciples of Jesus Christ have been given an important task of great significance.

Instead of baptizing the wars of our nations as somehow being blessed by God, we are given a greater opportunity to tell men everywhere of a greater blessing that is available to them because Jesus Christ has risen from the dead. Instead of telling the nations of the world that there are justified reasons for waging war, we are given the opportunity to tell men that they no longer have to destroy one another in any war whatsoever. For a new age has begun, where Jesus Christ rules and reigns, and a kingdom that knows nothing but the peace of Christ is now being offered to the sons of Adam, as a viable alternative to the hell that can come through war. We can proclaim that the nations never have to learn war anymore.

by Jimmy Humphrey
http://www.iamadisciple.com/articles/war_no_more.php

D
dietolive Dec 21, 2011

Hi Brother Jimmy! How are you these days?

A great, though-provoking article. One of the things your essay provoked in me when I read it was your mention several times of the concept of "nations" in relation to war-making. I think it is helpful to consider this term, and differentiate between the two parts, "the people" and "the State", that make up "the nation."

The State is that permanent organization that overrules a people in a certain territory. The State claims to possess a monopoly on ultimate decision-making, as well as an ultimate claim upon all property (taxes.) It also claims the right to kill anyone that tries to hinder its monopoly claims. By this definition for instance, we Americans all live under "the State."

On the other hand, the ancient Hebrew Republic (after the temporary theocracy of Moses and Joshua), was not a State, because there was no central authority that claimed a monopoly of ultimate decision-making and ultimate ownership of all property and lives. All this changed with the coming of the State under the first king, King Saul. (See I Samuel 8 to see what God and the prophet Samuel thought of "the State.")

Throughout history, we see that through lying propaganda and coercive intimidation, it is always the State that drives men to make war, not the other way around. And it is the people who fearfully and slavish obey it.

Therefore, if men are to learn to stop making war, the Church must realize that the State is not her friend. Whenever the State breaks Christ's law, it is her spiritual enemy. It's wicked commands are not to be obeyed, come what may.

Be well Brother.
Doug

K
KingJimmy Dec 21, 2011

Hey Doug!

I'm doing well. I've been pretty busy in recent months. I started a job at Wells Fargo as an underwriter. It's really been a major blessing in my life. How are you and your family?

Yes, there is definitely a difference between "the people" and "the State." Of course, in our system of government, there is supposed to be no difference... in theory. Regardless, you bring up a good point in showing that Christians should not lose their soul just because the State demands they do something contrary to the ways of Christ.

In the Nuremberg Trials, when asked why soldiers had comitted certain "war crimes," they all pleaded, "We were just following orders." As a result of just following orders, the Nazi soliders executed six million Jews. And in a sense of smug self-righteousness, we look at them as being monsters. But truth be told, at the end of the day, the ethics of the Nazi's were the same expectations of any soldier of our State. Just follow orders. Failure to do so, they say, will result in the death of your comrad on the battlefield.

And as a result of just following orders, our troops killed 150,000+ people in Iraq. And at the end of the day, the justification was some vague "war on terror" reasoning. And for the 4,000+ American soldiers that died, many family's console themsleves by saying that their sons and daughters died for the cause of freedom, and securing our liberty. And while there may be a hint of truth in such statements, it is not the full truth. It is just enough truth to deceive, and in reality, justify more war in the future.

The people of our nation need to hear a great truth, that there is a bold alternative to war. They need to realize that there is peace and freedom offered to them in the kingdom of God, as given by Him who sits on the throne of that kingdom. Nations never have to again learn war. The State no longer needs to send her sons and daughters to die in wars that no longer need to be fought. Even if they feel the war is morally just and necessary, as in the case of self-defense, there is still an alternative that goes beyond justice. There is the peace that comes through being a part of the kingdom of God.

Jimmy

A
ArtB Dec 23, 2011

Okay Jimmy, let's see how much you believe what you actually wrote.

A few men come to your house and demand that you hand over your son and daughter (let's assume you have a son and daughter) for the purpose of having unbridled sex with them for a few days. And when you say 'no' they ignore your pleas and proceed to take your son and daughter. Would you just let them take your children away, or would you bear arms and fight these men so as to protect your children from being abused?

This is the nature of war, that good men rise up with arms to protect the innocent from those bent on doing evil. If the United States did not intervene in World War II, the Axis powers would have won.

On the other hand, if it was just me, and some anti-Christian group seek to cut off my head because I'm a Christian, they are welcome to it, for I am not my body.

BTW, I read Augustine's writings and I am not at all impressed. I believe he was very misguided, too influenced by Plato and Manichean teachings, and in leaving his sexual addictions he swung to the opposite extreme which was equally bad (And the RCC took him as an authority on morality).

K
KingJimmy Dec 23, 2011

Let me answer your question with a few questions.

When men break into your house at night to kill you and your family, do you interview them first to find out if they are there to kill you becasue they are random thugs, or because they are there to kill you and your family because you are Christians? Does the reasoning of their response dictate how you as a Christian are to respond? If they are random thugs, should you shoot back at them? And if they are there to kill you because of your faith, only then should you submit? And if they do answer why they are there to kill you, how do you know they aren't lying?

Was not our own Lord led to the slaughter on bogus charges?

R
roadsign Dec 23, 2011

Art raises a common and legitimate concern:

Would you just let them take your children away, or would you bear arms and fight these men so as to protect your children from being abused?

Yet - what if you were a believer in almost any part of the world and in almost any age of history– with virtually no chance of winning with your “sword”? You and your family would more likely be exterminated on the spot if you resisted.

Here’s a thought to ponder: How have persecuted Christians themselves responded to threatening evil powers?
And what about those times when the church did have enough power to use the sword? Was there ever a time when the church did not itself become evil – even in its attempts to extirpate evil?

If the United States did not intervene in World War II, the Axis powers would have won.

Is this not what you are trained to believe? (Likewise, in Canada we keep hearing how it is the Canadians especially who helped bring victory in WW1)

Could Christians (including American believers) not have helped prevent war long before it started - if they had remained consistently obedient to their calling (as Jimmy describes).

Surely war, even when we “win”, is a tragedy because it reflects our human bent to abandon God’s peace plan through Christ Jesus.


Diane


K
KingJimmy Dec 23, 2011


Art raises a common and legitimate concern:

Most definitely. It is a very valid and legitimate concern. But in my opinion, such questions are really asking the wrong questions. As I addressed in my brief essay, the fundamental assertion of these questions is: "what are the the legitimate moral justifications for war?" It is my assertion that it doesn't matter if you find a legitimate moral justification or not for war. In my opinion, there are lots of legitimate justifications for it.

My thesis is that it doesn't matter if there are legitimate justifications for war. The fact of the matter is that Jesus Christ is King, and that He teaches us not to wage war, even if there are moral justifications. Instead of questioning what the moral justifications for war are, the real question is "Does Jesus Christ teach men to wage war?"

My assertion would be, no He does not. He teacches us that peace is a real alternative, and one that we should preach because He is king. War would end tomorrow if the nations would but respond to our preaching. War never ends because of war.

U
UntoBabes Dec 23, 2011

I just watched this video on SI channel that relates to this topic.

Check it out.

http://youtu.be/WrzWNsFt2vg


God bless.

J
Jeremy221 Dec 24, 2011

Hi KingJimmy,

I thought you made some good points and explained things well. In 2 Corinthians 4 which speaks of the sufferings of Paul and his coworkers for the Gospel. Paul makes a interesting statement that his sufferings are so that others might come to the knowledge of Christ just as Christ's own sufferings brought him to Him.

In light of this discussion, I believe it is important to remind everyone that we are in a battle whether we like it or not though it is not with flesh and blood. And yet, we are not our own but should walk according to the Spirit. Even Paul, who heralded by the fortune telling girl did not cast out the demon immediately but waited until he was moved. Yet, when he was moved, he suffered in the flesh being thrown in prison and mistreated as an example to the saints.

Paul stood in the gap for the saints regularly which is given evidence in the prayers recorded in the epistles and his comments about how he prayed for them. In this Day, there is yet no true pacifism. Just because one refuses to take up arms against a physical threat does not mean you are doing right.

We are to look unto Christ, who is unseen, to store up treasures in Heaven, that are unseen, and to battle spirits of darkness in heavenly places that are unseen because what is unseen is eternal. Until the Great and Glorious Day when Christ returns in glory when we shall meet Him in the air, we will fight for Christ's glory.

K
KingJimmy Dec 24, 2011

Awesome video. I've not watched the entire thing. I hope to this weekend.

sermonindex Dec 24, 2011

I did watch the video link from Untobabes. It is awesome. It brings reality to the last part of Romans 8. The question is do we take Jesus at his words or not? I think this also answers the question that Dietolive posed in the Polycarp thread.

Blaine

D
dietolive Dec 25, 2011

Quote:
"I did watch the video link from Untobabes. It is awesome. It brings reality to the last part of Romans 8. The question is do we take Jesus at his words or not? I think this also answers the question that Dietolive posed in the Polycarp thread."

I watched the whole thing, and no, it did not. But I am glad the Brothers who made it have like faith in the Lord Jesus. I wish them well in the good Lord.

Be well Brother Blaine.
Doug

This discussion is locked.

Archived
1 of 12 posts