BSBKJVWEBYLTASVBBEWMBT4TDBY|HymnsMusicDonate
Menu
Theology

Biblical cosmology

sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

Examine.

http://www.flatearthbible.com/flat-earth-in-the-scriptures-uncontested-revealed-truth/

"Flat Earth in The Scriptures Uncontested. Does the bible say the earth is flat
Revealed truth

Remember, what the apostle Paul said, "but test (or prove) everything; hold fast what is good!" (1 Thes 5:21 ESV)
Christians should not be afraid of investigating for the truth."

Edited to add quotation marks since those are not my words but the words accompanied by the video.

T
TrueWitness Sep 12, 2016

I can imagine millions of people rolling their eyes over this video. It wouldn't surprise me if this is the work of unbelievers trying to make Christians look foolish. We even have photos of Earth from satellites, moon missions, etc. that clearly show the Earth is a SPHERE.


P.S. I don't mind being ridiculed for believing the "foolishness of the cross". I am not trying to look good in the eyes of the world. But believing in a flat Earth is just plain wrong and false. The Biblical verses used to show a flat Earth are very weak and tepid. Not only do these people believe in a flat Earth but they also believe that the Earth is completely stationary and the Sun, stars and all planetary bodies revolve around the Earth.

-Daniel

sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

I wonder what would be our world view if we were living 200 years ago and only have the Bible and our own eyes as source of information...

P
proudpapa Sep 12, 2016

double post

P
proudpapa Sep 12, 2016

Isaiah 40:22 : "It is he that sitteth upon the circle of the earth,..."

John Gill 1697-1771 :

It is he that sitteth upon the circle of the earth,.... Or, "the globe (z)" of it; for the earth is spherical or globular: not a flat plain, but round, hung as a ball in the air; here Jehovah sits as the Lord and Sovereign; being the Maker of it, he is above it, orders and directs its motion, and governs all things in it:

sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

This is addressed in the video

T
TMK Sep 12, 2016

Tozsu-

Are you suggesting that you believe the earth is flat? I can't tell from your post.

I hope you don't believe such nonsense but again I can't tell from your posts.

sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

I did not tell you to believe it, I told you to examine it. Can examining something hurt you? I will believe what is proven to me. Thanks for the input.

F
forrests Sep 12, 2016

I have looked into this matter a bit - and I came across the interview I linked below. I haven't listened to it yet, but I plan to very soon. I believe the scientist in it is a Christian, and I think he is in the "God of Wonders" video.

I just thought it would be good to check out:

https://youtu.be/KbYbCB5Zj_E

C
Christinyou Sep 12, 2016

I don't live or did not live 200 years ago. If you have ever been to 35000 or 40000 feet in an airplane, you can see the curvature of the earth. If the earth is flat I am being deceived along with 1000s of others astronauts, pilots, camera's from space. Personal testimony from space and pictures prove the earth is a globe, and for an object to be in space and travel over the same spot on earth, the object has to be in perfect sink at a certain speed to keep up with the earths rotation, (satellite tv) The satellites speed proves the earth is round and rotating. At a hundred and twenty miles above the earth, the object has to travel pretty fast, but some objects are hundreds or thousands of miles in orbit, to keep up with the earths rotation it has to move with the surface of the earth and go round and round.

I don't think anybody knew this 200 or 2000 years ago.

In Christ: Phillip

sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

Thanks forrests for linking this video. I realize now that the scope of this topic way exceeds the possibilities of one thread, since outside of a biblical the FE has a cultural, a scientific, a psychological, a political. etc aspect, and we are not all experts so it would result in endless debate. Please allow me to narrow the topic to one question:
If we had the bible and our own simple observations and not have today's vast information from culture science etc. Would we come up with the idea that the earth is a sphere? The two Christians in the linked video state this and I strongly disagree, the way I see it the bible rather points to a flat earth than to a sphere.
Blessings,
Zsuzsanna

sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

Christinyou,
In the last year lot of people published the results of their own personal experiments on the internet, including amateur rockets, balloons, physics experiments and theories etc. that makes an average thinker question the one sided information that can be gained from modern textbooks, magazines etc. When I flew to Hungary this Spring I made pictures from the airplane the horizon was flat and rose to eye level. The windows of the airplane did not have distortion...
I ask the posters please stick to the bible text from now on to see whether it describes a flat or globe earth.
Thank you,
Zsuzsanna

sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

This is an old Athiests gotcha question. They usually ask it in context that the followers of Jesus are simple or uneducated and always were.

The thinking goes like this. If Jesus was God then why did he not tell mankind scientific truth concerning the cosmos? And why is it not recorded in the bible? I have never had a single one even try to rebut these versus when they see them and if it's good enough for athiest it should be enough here.

Jesus of course knew the earth was round and told us. He said in the "night" (a specific time at some point on the planet) and then mentions 3 different pairs of people doing things that happen at three different times on the earth, therefor the earth is round. I list them in their broadest terms.

In the field -8am til 4pm
At the mill - 4 pm til 12pm
In bed - 12pm til 8am

Luke- 17:34 I tell you, in that night there shall be two men in one bed; the one shall be taken, and the other shall be left. 35 Two women shall be grinding together; the one shall be taken, and the other left. 36 Two men shall be in the field; the one shall be taken, and the other left.

Marcmc

L
Lysa Sep 12, 2016

by Zsuzsanna
Please allow me to narrow the topic to one question:
If we had the bible and our own simple observations and not have today's vast information from culture science etc. Would we come up with the idea that the earth is a sphere? The two Christians in the linked video state this and I strongly disagree, the way I see it the bible rather points to a flat earth than to a sphere.

What?? You want to go back to 350ish BC? Because Aristotle found out and argued that the Earth was round about that time. Why did he do that? Because during a lunar eclipse, the earth's circular shadow was cast on the Moon. This was "his" simple observation not based on our vast knowledge and he didn't even have a Bible. Just a man and his eyes.

(edit: after i wrote this, I downloaded and listened to "
THE LIFE OF BROKENNESS BY WILLIAM MACDONALD" and then deleted the bottom half of post.

I left only the facts, Aristotle around 350BC with no Bible saw with his own eyes, as we see during every eclipse - the circular shadow of the earth.

God bless,
Lisa

D
docs Sep 12, 2016

It is with I hope a certain amount of fear and trembling and contriteness of my own self I offer this. But please good lady go to the website of those who made this film and spend some time there going over things they offer and advocate. That's all. You have made good posts and I have benefitted from them. So thank you for that.

sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

why?....why?

(I write in love, PLEASE don't mistake the tenor of my response, I BEG YOU)

you quoted Paul, so will I, then I will let Ian Paisley
speak for me.

" Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to care for the church of God, which he obtained with his own blood. I know that after my departure fierce wolves will come in among you, not sparing the flock; and from among your own selves will arise men speaking twisted things, to draw away the disciples after them."
Acts 20:28-30 (ESV)


"Fundamentalism Versus Apostasy" Ian Paisley
http://www.sermonaudio.com/playpopup.asp?SID=6863

be not cross with me, please, in Jesus love, neil

sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

I conclude that most of the readers find the idea of FE or geocentricity so absurd that they are not even willing to look at the scriptures.
Here is an article from ligonier ministries that dares to tackles this topic:
"Martin Luther and John Calvin believed geocentrism to be a true description of God’s creation."
http://www.ligonier.org/blog/luther-calvin-and-copernicus-reformed-approach-science-and-scripture/
docs, the Catholics believe that Jesus Christ the son of God died on the cross to bring us salvation. Should I not believe this idea because they are Catholics and worship Mary?
marc, According to current theories there are time zones in FE.
Lysa, I wanted to discuss the Bible not Aristotle.
Neil, Do you think that this idea is dangerous? It wasn't in the early church.

Thanks all the contributions they are good sources of information and have a humbling effect.

One more question:
How do you explain that God created the light and earth before He created the Sun and Moon while main stream science says that the earth came about from spinning dust in space? That would mean the Earth was always spinning and orbiting around the sun. Maybe when God created the Sun He also set the Earth in motion and on orbit?

God bless you.
Zsuzsanna


sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

What would Aristotle do with this kind of Lunar eclipse? He did not know about the supposed refraction.
http://abc7ny.com/science/tonights-lunar-eclipse-is-so-unique-its-impossible/340212/

D
docs Sep 12, 2016

From the film,

- There are no stars larger than earth

- The sun is not really ninety three million miles away

- The firmanent is really solid

- The heavenly bodies move and not the earth

/docs, the Catholics believe that Jesus Christ the son of God died on the cross to bring us salvation. Should I not believe this idea because they are Catholics and worship Mary?/

If the people who produced this film (worldslastchance) on a flat earth are the same people who maintain the website worldslastchance.com then there are issues. If they are not the same issues then I will be corrected. But if they are then they are anti-trinitarian and have a film denouncing the Trinity. Plus other unorthodox beliefs.

Plus under the articles section there is a article that is anti-semitic to its core and I say that with a great deal of trepidation because of the recent controversies and threads on SI relating to the Jewish people and Israel. I will not even go into the article. The air of unity on SI has been so exceedingly precious I dare not risk upsetting it. But perhaps you haven't perused their entire website or their beliefs and were just attracted to the article about the earth being flat. I'm done that before on websites. That is okay if you did but I would urge you to look around a bit on that website. I'm not trying to set myself up as better than you or anyone and I'm not comfortable saying what I have. No offense in any way is intended towards you. I believe the best of you and remember your many worthwhile contributions to SI.

"Doc"

sermonindex Sep 12, 2016

Thanks docs, I hoped to have a discussion about the Bible verses, the creation and biblical cosmology. We do not have to agree with one video, but may discuss the scriptures regarding those questions. I do not agree with the end time views of that video. There are lots of issues with the Catholics also but they got that one thing right...

This discussion is locked.

Archived
1 of 57 posts