BSBKJVWEBYLTASVBBEWMBT4TDBY|HymnsMusicDonate
Menu
General

Historical , source critism and textual manuscripts of the Talmud

D
deltadom Aug 14, 2022

I am wondering whether anyone any literature that deals with the Talmud from a scholarship level
As I am interested because the story of the Talmud is not as it seems like the Qur'an

To me to do even to do this type of work , I know working through the Talmud that you have different writers from different time periods and historical anakorisms just in one page and whether anyone has done any work regarding source critism.

It is also hard to find things such as Talmud manuscripts that make up the current Talmud

There is also Roman synchronism if you look into people like rabbi akiva from early sources

It is so hard to explain this to anyone

T
TMK Aug 14, 2022

Why are you so interested in the Talmud?

sermonindex Aug 14, 2022


The Jewish Talmud And Its Use For Christian Apologetics
https://www.equip.org/articles/the-jewish-talmud-and-its-use-for-christian-apologetics/


from the article:

In other places, the Talmud dramatically endorses the gospel narrative, albeit indirectly. In a book devoted to explaining why the Jewish rejection of Jesus was entirely reasonable, Orthodox Jewish scholar David Klinghoffer admitted:

The Talmud states that from forty years before the Temple’s destruction and onward, there were supernatural omens of the disaster to come ”” that is, starting from the inception of the Christian religion following the death of Jesus. The eternal fire of the Temple altar would not stay lit. The monumental bronze Temple gates opened by themselves. Josephus confirms the Talmud’s account of the inner Sanctuary’s east gate and its mysterious openings. He adds other portents from these years: a bright light shining around the altar and the Sanctuary at three in the morning, a cow brought for sacrifice giving birth to a lamb, apparitions of chariots and armies flying through the sky above the whole land of Israel.”8

Jewish anti-Christian apologist Rabbi Tovia Singer reluctantly admits:

In Tractate Yoma 39b, the Talmud…discusses numerous remarkable phenomena that occurred in the Temple during the Yom Kippur service…. There was a strip of scarlet-dyed wool tied to the head of the scapegoat which would turn white in the presence of the large crowd gathered at the Temple on the Day of Atonement. The Jewish people perceived this miraculous transformation as a heavenly sign that their sins were forgiven. The Talmud relates, however, that 40 years before the destruction of the second Temple [approximately AD 30 at the time of the Crucifixion] the scarlet colored strip of wool did not turn white.11

D
docs Aug 14, 2022

I don't see anything wrong with looking over the Talmud a bit and wanting to know more about it. Especially if it is for the purpose of knowing more about the Jewish people and how to better speak with them. Scripture remains foremost of course.

sermonindex Aug 14, 2022


the Talmud is a wicked document with the spirit of the antichrist in it. I would caution anyone reading it really unless you felt led for Jewish outreach. I have cautioned believers never to read source documents of pagan religions or wrong beliefs. The light exposes the darkness, to try and show errors in the dark or navigate there is a hard place. We are all prone to deception.

Many people I talked to who were reading the Koran or other false religions when pointedly asked have you read the entire Bible from cover to cover, many of them said "No." My response was always please read the entire bible every chapter and verse before you would even think of reading another religion.

We also all must be led by the Holy Spirit in our walks with Him.

D
docs Aug 14, 2022

For the sake of Jewish outreach is what I was thinking of. If my memory is correct, I've heard Dr. Michael Brown respond to people and Jewish people making reference to the Talmud. He can respond because he has taken the time to know a little about the Talmud. And again, Scripture is chief and foremost.

D
deltadom Aug 15, 2022

The only reason I want to do it is for jewish outreach , greg is right it is a dangerous book.
I just want to pull it a part from a scholarly level.

This discussion is locked.

Archived
1 of 7 posts