BSBKJVWEBYLTASVBBEWMBT4TDBY|HymnsMusicDonate
Menu
Theology

Once Saved Always Saved

J
JFEdgar Nov 17, 2005

Hello,The purpose of this post is to ask for testimonies of people who1.) once believed in OSAS/eternal security (and also what form of OSAS it was, whether it was the antinomian form or the calvinistic 'perseverence of the saints' form) etc and now do not, and why.2.) people who once did not believe in OSAS/eternal security (and also what form it was, whether antinomian or the calvinistic 'perseverence of the saints') and do believe in it now, and why. Am very eager to hear personal testimonies,Joe

A
Axe1338 Nov 17, 2005

No testimony but this is a lie from the enemy.Once saved always saved? So if I backslide completely I will still inherit the kingdom? No!Paul says: Shall we continue in sin that grace may abound? God forbid!!!

H
habakkuk3 Nov 17, 2005

I used to believe in OSAS because it was a doctrine taught in the denomination that I was a part of.At least in our church, we never studied Calvin or Arminius either as far as that goes.I'm not a theologian so I'll simply provide what the Holy Spirit told me. It was more of a rhetorical question but it adequately answered the question of OSAS in my heart and this was consistent with 1 John and many other scriptures. The question was simply "How can I be a follower of Jesus if I'm not really following Him?"This isn't a new question and if you do a search you will find a wealth of information on the topic. There's also an excellent book that has been mentioned on the site in the past by Dan Corner and here is his website: http://www.evangelicaloutreach.org/. If the Lord allows, I will post a more detailed response...

B
beenblake Nov 17, 2005

Dear Axe1338,So if I backslide completely I will still inherit the kingdom? No!I don't want to start a huge debate or such, (This topic has been debated once already). I just want to leave you with a question to think about. Is a person saved by faith or works? Can a person earn thier way into Heaven? If your answer is no, then I ask: How can a person earn thier way into Hell? In love,Blake

A
ApostleJoshW Nov 17, 2005

"For if we sin willfully after we have received the knowledge of the truth, there no longer remains a sacrifice for sins, but a certain fearful expectation of judgement, and fiery indignation which will devour the adversaries" Hebrews 10:26-27I believe this verse completely shoots down OSAS.

J
JFEdgar Nov 17, 2005

Well, let me explain a bit then.When I say the antinomian version of OSAS, I am referring to the doctrine that once you have been 'saved' (usually by saying a prayer) you may do whatever you want because you are "saved by faith"When I say the calvinistic, perseverence of the saints type of OSAS, I am referring to the doctrine that says you cannot continue in sin and be a Christian, however, the belief also holds that if you are truly saved God will automatically keep you from continuuing in sin. Those who backslide totally were never really saved, according to this doctrine. Also, I do not really want this post to be a place for debating the subject... I am really only looking for your personal testimonies as to why you do or do not believe in it. In order to keep this thread on-topic, if you would like to debate with someone about their reasons... I would ask that you either go to another thread or PM those people. Thanks,Joe

G
gzus Nov 17, 2005

When I wasn't a Christian I didn't know if I believed in eternal security or not; I didn't even know what it was. :-) However, since has God opened my eyes to see Him in His glory for who He was in all His majesty there has been no doubt in my mind that I will be spending an eternity with Him.God has done a transformation in my life that I cannot deny and I will never be able to deny. God has rescued me from my life of sin and changed my DESIRES to fix my eyes on Christ. I cannot just change my desires on my own, I especially cannot change my desires from loving sin and myself to hating sin and loving God. Praise God for this amazing gift of mercy and grace He has given to me and all who believe.And it is for this reason that "I am sure of this, that He who began a good work in me will bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ." - Philippians 1:6I would love to discuss further what God has done and has been doing in my life with anyone. I love to give glory to God my Father and Jesus Christ the Author and Perfecter of my faith.gzus777@gmail.comGrace and Peace,God Bless!

J
JFEdgar Nov 17, 2005

[I meant to send this in a PM]

G
gzus Nov 17, 2005

Killing sin is not a prescription of how to be forgiven//It's a description of the Christian who is forgiven//By trusting in the Risen Christ who took our wrath and affliction//Killing sin is not a prescription of how to be forgiven//It's a description of the Christian who is forgiven//And the Spirit now convicts them to put off and kill their sick sin// - Timothy Brindle, Killing Sinhttp://www.lampmode.com/

D
dann Nov 17, 2005

I used to believe that I could lose my salvation.To be sure I prayed a prayer to Jesus Christ, asking him to save me, and my hopes rested on whether I had prayed that prayer faithfully enough. Had I said the right words? Did I really, really, really, mean it? etc. I viewed my salvation, not in terms of the gospel as described in scripture, but in terms of whether or not I felt saved at that particular moment or not. To be certain – I rarely “felt” saved. Prior to coming to Christ my sins hardly bothered me at all – unless it meant I would get caught or humiliated on account of them. But once I saw myself as a sinner, and begged Christ to save me, my awareness of sin became overwhelmingly acute. Suddenly I saw that almost everything I thought, said, or did was sinful – and I began to repent with as much strength and power as a man can repent.The trouble was that I couldn’t repent enough to be free from the feeling that I had plenty of room to go – and consequently, I never “felt” saved. I would have bouts of horrible doubt – was I really a child of God? Yes, God had delivered me from all manner of sinful living – yes my life had turned a complete 180 degrees – yes I was now in love with God, and reading scripture, and prayer – but still I was failing in some areas. I redoubled my efforts – lived for weeks in prayer – yet that didn’t stave off the doubts. I felt I was losing my salvation every time I left the throne of grace – and soon, I wasn’t even sure I was saved when I came to that throne.None of this came from scripture mind you, I just felt that one who is saved ought to have some sort of salvation feeling – you know something esoteric, yet tangible, that one can inwardly check and instantaneously and unerringly determine whether or not they are a child of God or deceived: I overlooked some of the things in my own life:- the sudden sensitivity to sin - the radical shift away from wanting my own will accomplished and towards wanting God’s will accomplished - the sudden preference for goodie-two-shoes (Christians) who formerly made my skin crawl- the sudden hunger to read the bible- the sudden desire to know God more- the peace found in prayer- the new found joy in seeing God glorifiedI never would have considered that these things bore witness to the presence of God’s spirit in my life.Now, I don’t want to confuse the issue – I didn’t feel assured of my salvation is all I am saying. But there is a difference between being assured and being secured. If you had the blood of the lamb on your lentil and doorpost in Egypt that first Passover – you were secure. You might not have felt assured, but your assurance or lack of it didn’t change the fact that you were secure. You could be resting comfortably sleeping like a baby trusting entirely in the blood of the lamb to save you, or you could be wide awake fretting about whether or not you applied the blood the right way to the lentil and the doorpost – and worrying about whether you had enough of it, or if you put it on thick enough or what have you. Your fretting doesn’t change your security – you are under the blood because of the blood, and not because you were particularly good at putting it on your doorpost.In the same way, I don’t want to confuse assurance with security. One can be entirely secure and have absolutely no assurance whatsoever because they live their life in continuing sin, just as easily as one can be entirely lost – but presuming themselves saved, resting in a deluded form of false assurance.My point is that I was not assured of my salvation – and in the strength of my doubt I felt that I was alternately saved or lost depending on how well my walk was going. Most of my early faith therefore was not spent in pursuing Jesus, but rather in pursuing the feeling of being saved. The enemy kept me from growing very much spiritually in those days. My every thought was always and ever about whether or not I was a genuine believer, and so all my study and effort was focused on myself. I needed to stay saved, and as a result I wasn’t a very effective witness for Christ, being as I was, always and ever wrapped up in my own efforts to keep myself saved, or convince myself that I was saved in the first place.Now, praise the Lord, in this time I did have a tremendous hunger for God’s word, and in the strength of this hunger, I devoured the bible. I read it cover to cover again and again – many times. Eventually what I understand now to be the truth began to sink in.In the process of conception, not every sperm finds an egg to produce life, nor does every egg become fertilized. This might seem harsh and unfair to some – but most of us accept it without giving it much thought. Some believe it is all random anyway – but even these don’t weep for all the sperm and eggs that never produce a life. When life is conceived, it is fair to say that the life that is produced was not produced in any way of its own accord. That is, the child that is conceived had no say in the matter whatsoever – having not been a person until after conception.Birth therefore is the perfect picture of our own inability. While everyone that lives today was born at some time – none of us can say that we had any part in the decision to actually be born. We were passively brought into this live by forces outside our existence. Just as the wind blows wherever it blows – we see its effect, but we have no control over it whatsoever. So too everyone who is born in the flesh is acted upon by outside forces, and life is breathed into them by God, not because of anything they have done – but because God has chosen to do so. Yes, the babe’s heart beats, and the baby breathes – and learns to eat and drink etc – but the life comes from God, and only from God.Now even if we had no bible, creation itself demonstrates that life originates with God and not with man – that is what this pictures. Nicodemus was the teacher of Israel, but he missed that. Nevertheless, Christ himself uses the imagery of birth to picture the process by which God calls men to salvation.If men actually saved themselves this sort of imagery would be inaccurate (at best). Christ used the imagery of being born however, because it is a perfect image of what is going on spiritually. We have as much a role in our being “born from above” as we have in our having been born physically – and that is to say, none whatsoever.The wind blows wherever it wishes and though we hear the sound of it, we still cannot tell where it comes from or where it is going to – all we can do is sit and watch what it does. We have no active role in what the wind is going to do – we are spectators, and passive participants. So it is with those who are born of the Spirit, just as it was those who were born of the flesh – spectators, passive participants.When I began to see that scripture teaches that God saves sinners, as opposed to sinners using God as a means to save themselves – then I began to appreciate how secure my salvation truly was.You see, when I thought I was saving myself, I was working like crazy to stay saved – because my faith was in myself – that is, my hope rested on my own ability to keep myself saved. I wasn’t trusting God to save me – I was trying to save myself – and such a hope was sifting sand, as I was and ever will be, unable to keep the law perfectly as Christ kept it. Then I realized the truth – my righteousness, according to the gospel, doesn’t save me.I had to let that sink in. I knew it was true – it is the very gospel itself – but I began to let it really speak to me. I wasn’t saved in the first place by my own righteousness – in fact Jeremiah 19:9 tells me that all my “righteousnesses” are in fact unclean – that is, if I am relying on my own ability to be good to keep me saved – I am in fact relying on something that God Himself has openly declared unclean. What a mess I had made of it. Here I was trying to stay saved – how? By works of righteousness of course!Why did I do anything righteous? To prove to myself that I was saved – of course all the righteousness I was doing was a filthy rag to God – but I felt that if I was doing the best I could – praying, studying the bible, going to church, being sincere, etc., that these things were going to keep me saved. But the reality is that I wasn’t trusting in God to save me anymore – I was trusting in my own arm to keep me saved – and it was all contrary to scripture.Yes, I could find a dozen proof texts that seemed to say that I could lose my salvation – but I could also find in the rest of scripture a message that said loud and clear – God chose me and not vice versa. I was not saved by a faith that I generated but by a faith that was given to me as a gift - if my salvation was something I manufactured, then maybe I could unmanufactured it – but if God saved me, then I was saved indeed.I could pull up all the proof texts to demonstrate that I am saved by God, and eternally so, but you asked for testimony. If a man says a prayer in order to get into heaven, and having some assurance that no matter what he is going to go to heaven – if that same person embarks on a life of sinful liberty trusting his prayer to save him, and having no remorse continues to do so until he perishes – I do not doubt for a second that the man was a tare and not a wheat.If a man says a prayer, and continues in the church for years, excelling only to one day plummet away from the church never to come again, and professing to no longer believe – I do not doubt that the man is a tare and not a wheat.These have not lost their salvation – but have never been saved in the first place – their conversion was false, and whatever external evidence was given as witness to their salvation was not given in love of the Lord, but rather in love of self – to garner respect, or even to secure for themselves a certainty of their own salvation. Whatever the case – they went out from us because they were not of us – had they been of us they would not have gone out from us – but the fact that they did go out from us demonstrates that they were never really saved in the first place.So the person that falls away and “no longer believes” – according to the doctrine of the perseverance of the saints – as I understand it – and I think I have the common understanding – is not losing his salvation, nor is he keeping it – he was never saved to begin with.“Once saved always saved” doesn’t mean that if you say some salvation prayer you are saved no matter what – it means that if you are genuinely born again you will persevere to the end because you are genuinely born again. The fact that you persevere demonstrates the genuine nature of your salvation. If you fall away – it demonstrates that you were not genuine.Tares look like wheat – that is the problem.

J
jimbob Nov 18, 2005

Dann,Excellent post!My own experience is that I had begun as a Christian like a house on fire, and like most I was arminian in my thinking, I thought that I had come to Christ and that I had to maintain my standing in faith (there are after all several verses in the bible that imply that).After several years of intense bible study and searching for truth I came to the conclusion that the Bible was contradictory and powerless to change me. I fell away hard.After seven years of living a very un-Christian life, I was "spoken to" in the very center of my being. It was a clear voice, not my own, and He said to me "There's a better way".I've had my eye's opened to the truth found in John 6:37-39 "All that the Father gives Me will come to Me, and the one who comes to Me I will certainly not cast out....This is the will of Him who sent Me, that of all that He has given Me I lose nothing, but raise it up on the last day,"The Father gave ME to the Son before the foundation of the earth (Eph. 1:4) and the Son will not lose me. This is Gods' plan, all I do is rest in that plan. You might think this is too simple!!! Once I entered into His rest I had victory over the sins that used to dog me when, in my arminian mind set I used to struggle in my flesh to do what He had already done for me on the cross. Does this mean I have arrived? No, I have just begun. I feel sorry for those who believe they must do something to maintain a gift that was freely given, and pray that the eyes of our understanding would be opened to see ALL that the Father has for those whom he has called.

R
repentcanada Nov 18, 2005

I want to get back to this, but here is a favorite verse of mine - Matthew 10:22 - And ye shall be hated of all men for my name's sake: but he that endureth to the end shall be saved.AMEN!

D
dann Nov 18, 2005

repentCanada - amen to that.Only those who persevere are genuinely saved. Those who do not persevere (that is, those who go out from us) demonstrate that they are not saved (because they are not of us). Had they persevered (That is, if they remain amongst us), they would have demonstrated the genuine nature of the salvation - but anyone who can deny God doesn't have God's spirit - and never had God's Spirit.Only those with God's Spirit will endure.

P
PreachParsly Nov 18, 2005

When I was a very young Christian I was praying about whether OSAS is true. I felt the Lord speak to me and ask, "In the end, where are you saved from?" I said, "Hell." "When is it possible that you can go there?" I said," After I die?" "You must endure to the end."I don't think at all its debatable about the one who says," I've prayed a prayer and now I can do what ever because my flesh is weak and I live by faith." That person is going to Hell. It's a damnable heresy. Now the one who says, "I am once saved always saved. Look at my fruits. I strive to live a holy life before God. And God will not let me fall." Although I believe that you can "fall away", I would not take much or any time discussing it with them, unless of course they specifically asked. The first one on the other hand, I would do anything possible that they might see truth. A holy life is what is demanded, whether you believe that you can live unholy after you have came to the Holy One, or not.

N
Nasher Nov 18, 2005

Where does this fit into the equation:Hosea 14:4I will heal their backsliding, I will love them freely, For My anger has turned away from him.

P
PreachParsly Nov 18, 2005

Where does this fit into the equation:Perfectly! Right with these.1Jo 2:4 He that saith, I know him, and keepeth not his commandments, is a liar, and the truth is not in him.1Jo 3:8 He that committeth sin is of the devil; for the devil sinneth from the beginning. For this purpose the Son of God was manifested, that he might destroy the works of the devil.Jhn 15:1 I am the true vine, and my Father is the husbandman. Jhn 15:2 Every branch in me that beareth not fruit he taketh away: and every [branch] that beareth fruit, he purgeth it, that it may bring forth more fruit. Jhn 15:3 Now ye are clean through the word which I have spoken unto you. Jhn 15:4 Abide in me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit of itself, except it abide in the vine; no more can ye, except ye abide in me. Jhn 15:5 I am the vine, ye [are] the branches: He that abideth in me, and I in him, the same bringeth forth much fruit: for without me ye can do nothing. Jhn 15:6 If a man abide not in me, he is cast forth as a branch, and is withered; and men gather them, and cast [them] into the fire, and they are burned. Rom 11:22 Behold therefore the goodness and severity of God: on them which fell, severity; but toward thee, goodness, if thou continue in [his] goodness: otherwise thou also shalt be cut off.

G
Graftedbranc Nov 18, 2005

Now the one who says, "I am once saved always saved. Look at my fruits. I strive to live a holy life before God. And God will not let me fall." Although I believe that you can "fall away", I would not take much or any time discussing it with them, unless of course they specifically asked.You know, I believe we always look at the question from the wrong point of view. That is our performance, what is requried of us, etc. But we should step back and look at salvation from God's point of view and what it entails.To be saved is to be regenerated. That is through calling on the Lord Jesus Christ who died for us and resurrected, we believe into HIm and we are made alive in our spirit. Our spirit which is dead by nature is resurrected and indwelt by the Living resurrected Christ as the Life Giving Spirit.Can this be undone? No. Paul says, "the Spirit HImself witnesses with our spirit that we are children of God and if children, heir also. Heirs of God and joint heirs with Christ if so be that we suffer with Him.To be regenerated is to have God's life within us. It is to be born of God and to recive HIs very life and nature. That makes us heirs of God through birth.The Apsotle John says in 1 John 5: God has given us Eternal Life, this Life is in His Son, He who has the Son has the Life. He who does not have the Son of God does not have the Life."Eternal Life is not a place, a state, or a condition. Eternal Life is the Life of God which is in Christ and which we recive into us when we beieve into Him (John 3:16).Eternal Life is the Life of God which is Eternal in nature. On the Other hand, to be "joint heirs with Christ' requries us to "suffer with Him that we also might be glorified together with Him. To be born of God and to recieve His eternal Life only requires us to repent and believe into the Lord Jesus Christ and be born of God. But to be a joint heir with Christ in His Kingdom requires us to grow in Life, to mature, to suffer with Him and to be faithful. The Kingdom is a reward, but Eternal Life is the Gift of God which we do not earn by our works or by our this or that. We are born of God and have His life and therefore members of His household. It is not based in our performance.Having said that, if we are Born of God, it will bear fruit. We have HIs life within us and He has predestinated us to be conformed to the image of His Son that He might be the First Born among many brothers." God who has redeemed us, justified us, regenerated us, and is commited to sanctifying us will obtain what He has begun in us one way or another. If the scritpures are studied carefully, it will be seen that every reference to enduring and finishing our course and obtaining the "out resurrection of the dead, which are all conditional are always related to the reward of the Kingdom, not eternal Life. The Kingdom preceeds the New Jeruselem which is the consumation of the Bible and the eternal state of the redeemed, regenerated, sanctified, transformed, conformed, and transfigured believers.But the Kingdom and reigning with Christ for 1000 years is a reward to those who overcome and to those who are not slothful but are faithful servants who love HIm and suffer with Him, who deny themselves, take their cross and follow Him.Graftedbranch

J
JFEdgar Nov 19, 2005

Amen preachparsly.

L
letsgetbusy Nov 19, 2005

I used to lean a little towards both sides of the eternal security debate as a began to grow as a new born Christian. I think that the parable of the sower explains it all.In this line of thinking, those who are in good ground, and those in the thorny are both saved. One serves heartily, the other has as Alan Redpath put it, "a saved soul and a wasted life."The stony ground hearer is the one that shows outward evidence of salvation, but was never truly saved. The last type heard the Word but wanted no part of it.I don't see that God would save someone, and then unsave them. So I think this is the reason for all of the verses that speak of eternal security:John 10:28 "...they shall never perish, neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand."Rom 8:35 "Who shall separate us from the love of Christ?"1 John 5:13 "These things have I written unto you that believe on the name of the Son of God; that ye may know that ye have eternal life."Now in the same breath, I think the average person who says, "I'm saved," is not. Someone told them they were saved, or they were lead in a prayer, or maybe they just made their mind up they were to make others leave them alone. I told someone I was saved when I was young to make a guy leave me alone.After I was converted, I spent quite a while in distress not knowing if it was genuine. So while I don't think God 'unsaves' people, I think their are many who say they are, but know something is wrong, and really don't want to dig into the Word or talk with people about it, becuase they know that their true state will be exposed.Have I ever doubted my salvation? Yes. Because of how often I saw myself letting Christ down. How do I know I was saved? Because I was so convicted. And I still am whenever I ignore the Holy Spirit. The only way to have a good guess whether or not someone is saved is to spend much time with them, and even then they can fool you. The issue I bring forward is that just because someone shows some progress like: going to church, prayer, reading Scripture, etc, this does not mean they are saved. So my argument would be that just because we see people 'fall away', we cannot conclude that they lost their salvation. I say they were never cleansed with living water, they merely tasted the water. They hung around with the Holy Spirit for a while, and didn't like the idea of taking up a cross. These are the type that ring out with "ONCE SAVED ALWAYS SAVED." While I believe that statement, I don't find it anywhere in Scripture, nor do I think it does good from the pulpit. Just as "Jesus loves you" is true, but ineffective and incomplete as an evangelistic tool.There are multitudes of unsaved people who pass as saved, and multitudes of converted people that are very worldly. I don't sweat it as that will all be taken care of at the Judgment. Let's just make sure we will be able to stand on the day.2 Pet 1:10 "..make your calling and election sure.."

R
roadsign Nov 19, 2005

"For if we sin willfully after we have received the knowledge of the truth, there no longer remains a sacrifice for sins, but a certain fearful expectation of judgement, and fiery indignation which will devour the adversaries" Hebrews 10:26-27I believe this verse completely shoots down OSAS.Wow! Be careful to check the context! The writer is talking about the Israelites who had it all: the cloud, the pillar of fire, the laws, the Spirit of Christ in the desert, the manna,etc and YET they REFUSED. What else would save them? Nothing!! God gave them every chance. And so they were CUT OFF, like a branch, cut from the vine - as a nation/people group/. I think we have to distinguish between people groups and individuals. There will always be individuals who turn to the Lord, even if the goup they are a part of refuses as a whole, and even if God's judgment fall on them. Today we have it all - all that we need, and yet many REFUSE. They may look saved, act saved, but that doesn't mean that they have really ever ENTERED HIS REST. This debate goes on forever I think because of our weak understanding of salvation. When God saves someone he rescues them from themselves. Self is crucified. They become new creations. And if they are truely God's children, then he DISCIPLINES them to refine them. If he didn't NO ONE could hold on to their own salvation.Some questions: Does salvation depend on God or man? What is man's responsibility, and what is God's responsibility? There is much yet to think about before we can come to terms with this debate. Maybe we are often asking the wrong questions.Diane

This discussion is locked.

Archived
1 of 232 posts